In Rochester, New York, Monroe County Executive Maggie Brooks has threatened to pull Rochester Central Library’s funding because the library allows patrons to view pornographic material. In accordance with the Children’s Internet Protection Act, the library filters all internet connections, but to the displeasure of Brooks’ and many other citizens of Rochester, adults may request that filters be removed without being questioned as to why. As the Rochester Democrat and Chronical describes:
Patrons viewing unblocked Web sites are required to put tinted privacy screens on their monitors, and the library prohibits access to those sites on the main floor and parts of the second floor — areas with the most traffic and with children’s sections nearby.
The firestorm touched off following a WHEC investigative report:
With a hidden camera, we made a half dozen trips to the library, and on nearly every visit, we found someone looking at porn. We saw a man viewing images of naked people engaged in sexual acts. Standing nearby, we could see it all.
The library, in response, has temporarily halted the unblocking of filtered websites, and has issued this statement, which reads in part:
TV coverage has suggested that we could do more to prevent inadvertent viewing and we will study ways to insure that this is the case…. Filtering of content has been an inexact science and has resulted in blocking sites with legitimate content. As a corollary, to request unblocking of filters is not necessarily an admission or declaration of wrong-doing or bad intent. Put differently, not all people who wear trench coats are spies.
A measured response and a call for dialogue on the issue may be ineffective in the face of public outcry. Facing the threat of a complete budget cut, Rochester Central may have little choice but to agree to censor their patrons.
To voice your support or complaint, contact information for the Monroe County Exucutive can be found on her website.